How to best order user content on landing page?

I am thinking of a new way to order my scenarios on the main page of Currently I use the top likes/responses, but it gets a bit stale and I am missing a quick way to see cool 'new' reactions or scenarios.

So perhaps I want to add something like most recently added or replied to, but I don't want each new scenario to end up there immidiately.... Anybody have a good source for some options?

For new users show your best content (top likes/responses or manually curated). For returning users show fresh content. You can set a cookie to check.

Maybe make it manually filterable too like the questions here. With an option to see popular scenarios, unanswered ones, etc.

I implemented user changeable sorting and stored it :) Let's see if this feels good :) Thanks!