"I am afraid of people leaving" -- I've been there, and in reality the answer is that nobody cares. If you change something and they really care, they will yell at you to change it back.
Right now you are battling indifference, so I would try anything that changes that.
Also, have you tried emailing the people who have purchased from you to see if they are satisfied, and what you could do in order to sell them more templates (if they are happy)? That might give you some ideas too.
One more thing! You might want to consider offering them options. For example $99 for ALL the themes currently available on the site (only 2x more than just buying 1 theme, but who cares), and then $199 for all Curren themes, plus ALL future themes... You may never upload any more themes at all, but who cares, more money!
"I am afraid of people leaving" -- I've been there, and in reality the answer is that nobody cares. If you change something and they really care, they will yell at you to change it back.
Right now you are battling indifference, so I would try anything that changes that.
Also, have you tried emailing the people who have purchased from you to see if they are satisfied, and what you could do in order to sell them more templates (if they are happy)? That might give you some ideas too.
I did aswell, but now I have no email marketing, I moved from Lemon to Polar.
I barely gave support tickets, maybe once a month, and it's about the payments platform, sometimes for the themes but is not a trivial help they need.
I do talk to them on the discord channel though.
They don't care, I guess you are right, I just feel uncomfortable pushing sales and putting it in their face... I guess I have to change my mind...
One more thing! You might want to consider offering them options. For example $99 for ALL the themes currently available on the site (only 2x more than just buying 1 theme, but who cares), and then $199 for all Curren themes, plus ALL future themes... You may never upload any more themes at all, but who cares, more money!
That's what I have 99 fir one theme.
I used to have 199, but price went up to 299.
I am redesigning and creating more thenes currently at 31